The Vault
Network Slicing the Key that Unlocks 5G Revenue Potential - Where 5G Meets SDN / NFV
In order for network slicing to deliver on its promise as an effective tool to generate new revenues and profitability, new business models must match the dynamic technical and operational changes that it brings. Significant progress is being made in demonstrations and trials, as highlighted in this report and the accompanying RCR Wireless Webinar with Strategy Analytics, InterDigital and BT, yet more remains to be done.
What should operators and vendors do in 2018 to prepare for network slicing as they move toward commercial 5G deployments?
Strategy Analytics and thought leaders from InterDigital, Intel and operator participant BT outline a call to action to advance dynamic E2E 5G network slicing and ensure it delivers on the promise of 5G.
Service Providers
www.strategyanalytics.com
December 2017
Susan Welsh de Grimaldo and Sue Rudd
Email: swelshdegrimaldo@strategyanalytics.com
srudd@strategyanalytics.com
Dynamic End-to-End 5G Network Slicing holds promise as
the key to unlocking revenue growth in 5G networks.
Strategy Analytics, along with thought leaders from Intel and
InterDigital and learnings from BT, examine the 5G network
slicing value proposition, real world progress to date and key
challenges still needing to be addressed.
The industry is challenged with a “call to action” to focus on
what operators and vendors should do in 2018 to prepare for
network slicing as they move toward commercial 5G
deployments.
Service Provider Strategies (SPS)
Network Slicing the Key that Unlocks 5G Revenue Potential –
Where 5G meets SDN/NFV
Report Sponsors:
In collaboration with:
Additional conversation with:
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 2 of 19
Contents
Executive Summary 3
1. Business Issues: Is Slicing the Key to 5G Promise? 4
1.1 The Promise of Network Slicing to Drive New Revenue Streams Efficiently 4
1.1.1 Network slicing Is all about the services 4
1.1.2 How many slices will be needed in a typical network? 5
1.1.3 What is the value proposition for services of dynamic end-to-end network slicing in 5G? 6
1.1.4 Is network slicing really the key to new 5G revenue and justify network investments? 7
1.2 Business Benefits beyond Revenue Generation: Slicing Promises Much More 8
2. State of Pre-5G Network Slicing 9
2.1 Industry PoCs and Trials for Network Slicing 9
2.2 Service Provider Examples 10
3. Technical and Operational Challenges to Fulfil the Promise of Network Slicing 13
4. A Call to Action and Key Questions to Assess 15
4.1 A Call to Action 15
4.2 Key Questions 16
5. About the Sponsors 17
5.1 5G End-to-End: What Intel Brings to the Table for Dynamic Slicing 17
5.2 InterDigital: Developing Key Standards, Building Blocks for 5G Network Slicing 18
6. How Can We Help You? 19
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 3 of 19
Executive Summary
Dynamic End-to-End 5G Network Slicing holds promise as the key to unlocking revenue growth in 5G
networks.
5G is not only the next generation platform for future innovation but also a service enablement platform for
engaging verticals and enhancing mobile broadband for consumers. 5G is about business transformation and
new business models for Communications Service Providers (CSPs). Network slicing is a mechanism that will allow
CSPs to dynamically allocate network resources in ways that will maximize customer value and enhance
differentiated services, so that 5G can serve new purposes, adapt to specific needs and drive revenue
opportunities.
Network slicing allows CSPs to “segment one big broadband network into multiple virtual networks to serve verticals
and applications in a more cost efficient manner”, as described in by 5G Americas. Slicing separates the network
based on services; and the reason to create slices is to serve diverse business purposes with different Class or
Quality of Service (Cos/QoS). With dynamic E2E network slicing, the industry can begin to move to a model where
services expand and contract their use of network resources as traffic demands. 5G network slicing is expected to
deliver service agility, enhanced security, and “just fit” services for enterprises, among many other service specific
benefits. In particular, network slicing will enable CSPs to offer Network as a Service (NaaS), with new MVNO or
partner models for verticals and specific segments/use cases.
In order for network slicing to deliver on its promise as an effective tool to generate new revenues and profitability,
new business models must match the dynamic technical and operational changes that it brings. Significant progress
is being made in demonstrations and trials, as highlighted in this report and the accompanying RCR Wireless
Webinar with Strategy Analytics, InterDigital and BT, yet more remains to be done.
What should operators and vendors do in 2018 to prepare for network slicing as they move toward
commercial 5G deployments?
Strategy Analytics and thought leaders from InterDigital, Intel and operator participant BT outline a call to
action to advance dynamic E2E 5G network slicing and ensure it delivers on the promise of 5G.
“At the end of the day, we need to make sure that the costs of operating these
multiple virtual networks doesn’t exceed the additional revenues we are
expecting to get from those services” Maria Cuevas, BT
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 4 of 19
1. Business Issues: Is Slicing the Key to 5G Promise?
1.1 The Promise of Network Slicing to Drive New Revenue Streams Efficiently
1.1.1 Network slicing is all about the services
While the industry has not fully fleshed out the functionality of network slicing, it is a network architecture
that allows service providers to create multiple logical networks that can be assigned to different
services/service types running over a common physical infrastructure, explains Maria Cuevas, Head of
Mobile Core Network Research, BT. Network slicing “segments one big broadband network into multiple virtual
networks to serve verticals and applications in a more cost efficient manner”, as described in a 5G Americas
whitepaper “Network Slicing for 5G Networks & Services.”
In an RCR Wireless Webinar with Strategy Analytics, Akbar Rahman, Sr. Principal Engineer, InterDigital,
explains that 5G slicing offers richer functionality to address business needs than existing VLAN, VPN, QoS and
virtualization approaches that aim to meet many of the same needs on today’s networks. The vision for dynamic,
End-to-End (E2E) Network Slicing in 5G involves allocating a customized virtual slice of computing, storage and
networking resources at an E2E IP network level for given users (tenants). A November 2017 GSMA report, “An
Introduction to Network Slicing,” defines network slicing from the mobile operator’s point of view – “a network slice is
an independent end-to-end logical network that runs on a shared physical infrastructure, capable of providing a
negotiated service quality. The technology enabling network slicing is transparent to business customers.”
The most recent September 2017 3GPP 5G Service Requirements (3GPP TS 22.261 V15.2.0 Release 15 Stage 1)
are designed to allow “the operator to provide customized networks. For example, there can be different
requirements on functionality (e.g., priority, charging, policy control, security, and mobility), differences in
performance requirements (e.g., latency, mobility, availability, reliability and data rates), or they can serve only
specific users (e.g., MPS users, Public Safety users, corporate customers, roamers, or hosting an MVNO).”
And 3GPP explicitly notes that “A network slice can provide the functionality of a complete network, including radio
access network functions and core network functions (e.g., potentially from different vendors). One network can
support one or several network slices.”
Initial provisioning of network slices for a variety of service types is relatively static with one or more service flows
sharing a dedicated slice for their particular class of service, and each service flow being assigned to a particular
network slice as needed. Going forward the goal is to make the process more dynamic with resources being
assigned as required in real time.
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 5 of 19
Exhibit A. Dynamic Network Slicing for E2E Services
Source: Strategy Analytics
Slicing separates the network based on services; the reason to create a slice is to serve business
purposes. With dynamic E2E network slicing, the industry will be able to move to a model where services can
expand and contract their use of network resources as traffic demands.
1.1.2 How many slices will be needed in a typical network?
Some slices will meet the needs of broad horizontal markets; some will be assigned to specialized vertical markets;
and some will be specific to a particular customer.
For example:
x A customer will be able to have its own slice, share a slice with other tenants, or have services running
over multiple slices
x End user equipment (UE) will eventually be able to attach separate application service flows to different
slices at the same time from the same device, and applications could even trigger a switch between slices
x A vertical industry may in the future contract for multiple slices to serve its use cases with different
service quality and performance requirements that are guaranteed E2E with Service Level Agreements
(SLAs) just as dedicated networks are today
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 6 of 19
Exhibit B. 5G Network Slices Running on a Common Underlying Multi-vendor and Multi-access Network
Each slice is independently managed and addresses a particular use case
Source: IEEE Communication s 0517 ‘Network Slicing for 5G with SDN/NFV: Concepts, Architectures, and Challenges’
The number of slices will depend on the diversity of customer service requirements and the service providers’ ability
to guarantee E2E Quality of Service (QoS) with available physical resources and a good business case. Intel’s Dr.
Geng Wu, Chief Technologist and Director of Wireless Standards and Advanced Technology, guides that
beyond initial incorporation of standards around some limits on the number of slices—i.e. how many slices are
supported per UE—the optimal number of slices will be based on implementation and deployment; and that over
time industry will learn through an iterative process what works best. With dynamic slicing, the number of slices may
even vary in real time as resources are spun up and spun down as needed.
1.1.3 What is the value proposition for services of dynamic end-to-end network slicing in 5G?
5G is the next generation platform for future innovation and a service enablement platform for engaging
verticals and enhancing mobile broadband evolution for consumers. 5G is about business transformation and
creating new business models. Who offers services, who uses services, what services are offered and how they are
packaged will shift, as 5G enables new business models, and potentially new types of service providers. Network
slicing is a mechanism for assigning network resources in different ways so that 5G can serve new purposes and
adapt to specific needs that will in turn drive revenue opportunities.
In 5G networks, dynamic E2E slicing is anticipated to enable:
x Service agility to flexibly meet market demand and respond to competition, as pointed out by BT’s Maria
Cuevas, Head of Mobile Core Network Research (in an RCR Webinar with Strategy Analytics)
x Delivery of “just fit” as needed service requirements for most cost efficiency and enhanced
performance for a “pay for what you need” economy, as noted by Caroline Chan, VP and GM, 5G
Infrastructure Division, Network Platform Group, Intel, with an ability to spin up and down as required
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 7 of 19
x A new model of service onboarding and management (eventually with self-service) for large
enterprise/verticals and MVNOs
x Ability to optimize for price and performance for specific services
x Enhanced security, with customization on specific encryption techniques, isolation
x Ability to span administrative boundaries (e.g. network slice going between two operators for a
national smart grid, or federated slicing for global reach of services)
Exhibit C. Telstra Motivations for Network Slicing
Source: Telstra, “Telstra: Network Slicing to tailor the network architecture per user segment,”
Network Slicing Summit 2017, 5 Dec 2017.
1.1.4 Is network slicing really the key to new 5G revenue and justify network investments?
As operators plan for 5G investments, a top consideration is how they will generate revenues and a return
on their 5G Investment (RoI). Dynamic end-to-end (E2E) network slicing is the key to enable 5G business cases
across multiple verticals.
BT characterizes three types of revenue related opportunities it sees for operators from slicing:
1) Rapid deployment of new services without disrupting existing slices, in order to gain the agility to
compete and meet market demands
2) Ability to support different operational models for service deployment with a range of different SLAs
3) Ability to support a growing range of customer types that will have mutually conflicting functional
requirements; virtual slices can support these conflicting needs at the same time on the same infrastructure
and optimize for these requirements
“How do you know 5G will be successful? I don’t. The only way to do it is actually go in and
learn,” says Intel’s Caroline Chan, highlighting learnings in trials with vertical enterprises and
calling for the wireless industry to expand its ecosystem for 5G to work with enterprise
customers on business case development.
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 8 of 19
In particular, network slicing will enable Network as a Service (NaaS), with ability to offer new MVNO or
partner models for verticals and specific segments/use cases.
In order for network slicing to deliver on its promise of being an effective tool to generate new revenues and
profitability, there are mindset changes and business model challenges still to be worked out, notes BT’s Maria
Cuevas. In parallel, Intel’s Caroline Chan says the industry will need to adjust how it does contracts in a new model
of dynamic service slices.
1.2 Business Benefits beyond Revenue Generation: Slicing Promises Much More
What business benefits beyond revenue growth can operators address with slicing?
While much focus is being given to the ability to drive new service revenues with network slicing’s service-centric
architecture, there are additional benefits to operators to be gained by implementing slicing on 5G networks. Some
of these benefits will facilitate operations while others will improve the experience for the users.
For example, network slicing is expected to:
x Optimize traffic & load management
x Simplify wholesale and MVNO provisioning
x Facilitate critical 5G IoT, Connected Cars and Ultra-Reliable and Low-Latency Communications (URLLC)
on the same network infrastructure
x Guarantee customer experience
x Enable seamless E2E fixed and mobile VPNs with bandwidth on demand for enterprise customers
x Facilitate SLAs across new partner ecosystems
x Enable the ability to dynamically move resources where needed for compute and storage for more efficient
use of resources, combined with MEC and AI, as described by Intel’s Caroline Chan; and drive network
efficiencies across the board through dynamic resource allocation to slices
x Isolate complex issues into something manageable, by disaggregating infrastructure, implementation and
management, as explained by Intel’s Dr. Geng Wu
x Elastically adjust bandwidth, QoS, topology, etc., of assigned network slices based on using big data
machine learning (ML) techniques to monitor behavior of user traffic on a given network slice, resulting in
reduced cost for the tenant and increased network efficiency for the operator, as described by
InterDigital’s Akbar Rahman
“At the end of the day, we need to make sure that the costs of operating these
multiple virtual networks doesn’t exceed the additional revenues we are
expecting to get from those services” Maria Cuevas, BT
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 9 of 19
2. State of Pre-5G Network Slicing
2.1 Industry PoCs and Trials for Network Slicing
Multiple service providers, vendors, standards development organizations (SDOs), research institutes and
associations are working to make network slicing real for 5G. Technical trials, Proofs of Concept (PoC), R&D and
business case development (e.g. for enterprise extranets or industry verticals) are providing hands on learning and
establishing the value of network slicing. In advance of 5G, however, a number of the proposed features and
functions of network slicing are already being tested on today’s LTE networks with 5G standards in mind.
The large industry players are working hard with service provider partners and a selection of their recent network
slicing trials are shown below.
Exhibit D. Selected Network Slicing Demonstrations
Source: Strategy Analytics
In November 2017 another Next Generation initiative, Telecom Infra Project (TIP), formed a new E2E Network
Slicing Project Group, chaired by BT and HPE, to identify, develop, demonstrate and trial use cases for network
slicing in a multi-vendor, multi-domain and multi-operator context. NGMN, ETSI, 3GPP, TM Forum and 5G-PPPare
among the industry organization working to co-ordinate these efforts and complete the network slicing
Month/Yr
CSP &
Partner
Vendor,
Consortium
Network Slicing Demonstration or Project
Oct.2015 SK Telecom Ericsson Demonstrate 5G network slicing technology for Augmented Reality, Internet of Things and Enterprise solutions
Nov. 2016 Deutsche Telekom Huawei Demonstrated E2E Slicing for 5G RAN
Feb. 2017 SK Telecom, BMW Ericsson ‘First 5G Federated Global network slicing’
May 2017 NTT DOCOMO Ericsson Live demo of Network Slicing for Robotics
May 2017 BT Huawei Research 5G Network Slicing for Live Event User Video & MWC 2018
May 2017 5G-PPP NORMA Presents E2E mobile network architecture for rapid implementation
June 2017 5G-PPP MONARCH Diverse services, use cases, and applications in 5G
July 2017 China 5G trials ZTE, Demonstrates network slicing, 19 Gbps speeds
Sept. 2017 Telefónica Nokia evaluate 4.5G Pro, 4.9G technologies & Evolution to5G for massive MIMO, Cloud RAN, Multi-access Edge Computing and Network Slicing
Oct. 2017
Verizon,
Vendor
Demos
Ericsson, Nokia Network Slicing for SD-WAN VPNs demonstrated at SDN World Congress
Nov 2017 BT, Univ. Bristol Nokia 5G Testbed for Urban Apps. Network Slicing
2018 TIM Torino
incl.
MONARCH
Multiple Field Demonstrations
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 10 of 19
specifications. GSMA Future Networks programme is also working on the topic of network slicing business case
development.
Most of the trials listed above are testing relatively static slices with pre-assigned applications per slice but working
on mechanisms that allow the network to monitor and dynamically optimize the slice performance to ensure that
service providers can guarantee SLAs with ‘network elastic’ slices. Since TCP/IP guarantees only ‘Best Efforts’ and
has no flow management, two of the major vendors are providing their own internal flow management so that
multiple service flows can share a slice to lower costs below those of a ‘nailed up’ VPN or MPLS tunnel.
2.2 Service Provider Examples
Some of the most interesting demonstrations of network slicing to date have been for global remote Connected
Cars, Software Defined Multi-Data Center connectivity and High Performance Secure Enterprise VPNs. Many of
these were described by Strategy Analytics in the October 2017 Webinar, “Analyst Angle Webinar: Network Slicing:
The Key that Unlocks Revenue Potential”.
Verizon, for instance is focused on Software Defined Networking (SDN) for network slicing that supports slices for a
variety of diverse use cases from smartphones to autonomous driving and massive IoT as shown in the exhibit
below.
Exhibit E. Verizon SDN Controlled Network Slicing for Diverse Slices
Source: Verizon SDN-NFV Reference Architecture 2016
Much of the latest focus, however, has actually been on the essential operational capabilities that are needed to
ensure performance and develop management and network and service orchestration mechanisms for these
diverse services.
For example, the 5G-PPP sponsored Mobile Network Architecture (MONARCH) trial that started in August 2017
and which will run through mid-2019 has a “specific technical goal …to use network slicing (to) capitalize on the
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 11 of 19
capabilities of SDN and NFV with orchestration of access network and core network functions, and analytics, to
support a variety of (diverse) use cases in vertical industries such as automotive, healthcare, and media.” Partners
include: Deutsche Telekom, Telecom Italia, Nokia Bell Labs France, Huawei Technologies and Samsung
Electronics. There are several testbeds including Hamburg which will demonstrate a Smart Sea Port with Traffic
Light Control, Video Surveillance and Sensor based mMTC for barges and wireless terminals. The Venice trial will
demonstrate Tourist City capabilities for Virtual Reality and Immersive, Co-operative Media. See the Exhibit below.
Exhibit F. 5G MONARCH: Orchestration and Inter-Network Slice Control
Source: 5G-PPP 5G MoNArch presentation, Brussels, June 1st, 2017
These demonstrations and trials should ensure not only that the necessary technology is developed for commercial
deployment in the next couple years, but also that there are proven and profitable business use cases for both
service providers and their customers.
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 12 of 19
In a recent study with BT, Ericsson attempted to estimate some of the financial benefits that 5G network slicing
could provide for operators.
Exhibit G. Ericsson Study Shows Cost Savings from Network Slicing
Source: Ericsson Study: How Network Slicing Pays Off Sept 20, 2017
The study shows that network slicing enables new revenue generation, and lower OPEX and greater CAPEX
efficiency, resulting in significantly increased incremental contribution to the bottom line through new service
launches. Network slicing, with cost-effective deployment of operational automation, will become the most
economical way to manage service scalability. Ericsson notes that “the economic benefits are seen even with a
small number of service launches. Benefits then increase with the scale of services added thereafter.”
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 13 of 19
3. Technical and Operational Challenges to Fulfil the
Promise of Network Slicing
While some practical implementations of network slicing—such as fixed and mobile enterprise VPNs with E2E
SLAs—can be offered in the near future, there are some significant barriers to the full deployment of dynamic
network slices for many demanding classes of low latency or high volume service. Some serious technical problems
for network slicing remain that will require additional research. Many others have no simple traditional solutions.
These translate to some fundamental challenges for network slicing that include:
x How to guarantee Quality of Service (QoS) with a high degree of certainty
– Network slicing is all about matching the right Class and Quality of Service or QoS to every
application—for example, real time two-way video and scheduled file downloads would be assigned
to different slices that meet different parameters i.e. different latency, bit loss, throughput, etc. If
network slices and E2E QoS guarantees can only be delivered over fixed VPNs or MPLS tunnels
with dedicated physical resources they just become silos of ‘nailed up’ assets that cannot be
allocated dynamically—undermining the value of the dynamically shared NFV network.
x Performance issues in a shared infrastructure
– Problems of resource overprovisioning are likely to occur if there is ‘hard partitioning’ of network
slices, but if slices share resources then new mechanisms and policies are needed to avoid
contention and ensure QoS for each slice.
x Inherent contradiction between ‘nailing up’ VPN resources to guarantee SLAs for network slicing
vs. true NFV virtualization
– If ‘hard partitioning’ means that network resources can only be virtualized within a slice a major
NFV benefit of maximizing capacity utilization with the dynamic allocation of all network resources
from a ‘virtualized network pool’ could be severely reduced.
x Management and orchestration issues
– Given the dynamism and scalability that slicing brings, management and orchestration in
multiservice flow scenarios are not straightforward. Slices need resources to be assigned ‘on the fly’
and resource demands may vary dramatically in very short time intervals, both within and across
slices.
x End-to-End services vary in ‘scope’ of a slice
– Many descriptions of network slicing assume that the scope of a slice must always go across the
entire network from a user application to a server in the heart of a fixed network or another user on
the other end. But in fact we are now in a world where some services may stay within the Radio
Access Network (RAN) while others may go directly between data centers in the core. Still others
may move dynamically around the Telco Cloud as required. So E2E requirements will vary widely in
scope and complexity.
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 14 of 19
x Business models must become diverse and flexible to match the services
– The allocation of network resources per flow/slice can become highly dynamic and the business
models for pricing etc. may sometimes need to match the dynamic traffic variations and even SDN
controlled bandwidth allocations. Other prices may, however, not even be based on traditional
throughput or usage metrics. Instead CSPs may be able to charge for QoS delivered or the value of
low latency of high performance results.
Key technical problems for network slicing for which solutions are still in process include:
x How to guarantee QoS in a packet queuing environment where even DiffServ can only guarantee ‘best
efforts’
x Building blocks that need to be completed
– Dynamic VNF flows and configurable service chains
– E2E service orchestration
– Tools for automated creation, activation and management
– Slicing the RAN
– Optimizing edge computing
And some critical questions remain that must be answered if network slicing is to fulfil its potential:
x How do we characterize application/service flow requirements to the network in real time?
x What parameters do we use? Latency? Bandwidth? Burstiness/Variability?
x How do we assign incoming service flows dynamically to slices?
x How do CSPs switch application/service flows between slices?
x What is the role of TOSCA templates for slicing in the Telco Cloud?
x What is the impact of ‘Slicing the RAN’ and adding MEC Services at the Edge?
x How many slices do we need?
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 15 of 19
4. A Call to Action and Key Questions to Assess
4.1 A Call to Action
Significant Progress on Network Slicing Requirements but new Approaches and Standards Needed
What should operators and vendors do in 2018 to prepare for network slicing as they move toward
commercial 5G deployments?
x Increase enterprise and vertical engagement and active participation in the 5G ecosystem: further
collaboration with enterprises and verticals is needed to support joint development of requirements for slicing and
business cases that drive value to service providers and their customers
x Learn through doing: As Intel’s Caroline Chan advises, learning through doing in trials is a crucial process for
developing 5G network slicing; incorporating learnings back into R&D and standards and further trials in an
iterative and collaborative process will further address both business and technical challenges as the industry
moves toward commercial 5G deployments
x Work on process and organizational changes that are needed to implement 5G network slicing: in addition
to the technical and operational challenges, operators face challenges to transform processes and even mindsets
and company culture to prepare for 5G and be ready to use slicing as a revenue generation and cost efficiency
tool: e.g. contract processes will need to change. BT notes every part of the value chain must be much faster
than today for agility across the service lifecycle, and partnerships will require commercial agreements with well-
defined SLAs and ability for slices to work across multiple administrative domains.
x Develop common definitions of slices and their parameters across operators: BT’s Maria Cuevas
recommends a template to describe slices. As Akbar Rahman of InterDigital explains, operators will need a way
to advertise the APIs for network slices. BT sees the GSMA as having a critical role in developing these common
definitions and the operator is working on this effort with the GSMA.
x Work on incorporating machine learning, analytics and AI into the development of network slicing and
use case trials as much as possible, to aid in automation, fault prediction and self-healing, as well as improved
experience for the services and tenants on slices.
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 16 of 19
4.2 Key Questions
Collaborate on addressing key questions:
x How best to slice for cost efficiency while maximizing end user value and enabling value based pricing?
x How to optimize overall network performance and network scalability alongside network slicing?
x How to reduce the complexity of network slicing through automation and orchestration?
x How to ensure that dynamic slicing will drive the envisioned capex/opex savings through efficiently shared
resources and deliver elastic scaling based on demand?
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 17 of 19
5. About the Sponsors
5.1 5G End-to-End: What Intel Brings to the Table for Dynamic Slicing
In 5G, Intel is focused end-to-end, playing an important role of trusted advisor, technology partner and
ecosystem builder. As Sandra Rivera of Intel said, while 5G is the fifth generation of RAN, it is the first generation
of fully distributed compute power in the network—and Intel is bringing its expertise in the IT network world to bear
in developing and supporting 5G as a distributed computing network.
Intel is active in standardization activities, such as the service architecture group in 3GPP and ETSI MEC task
group (Multi-Edge Compute impacts service delivery enablement for slices), and open source development, for
example in the Telecom Infra Project (TIP).
Intel’s 5G related products and solutions span from chipsets and device partnerships, IoT and enterprise groups,
autonomous vehicles, cloud services and data centers, to AI and machine learning, among others. On the network
side, Intel is very active on NFV resource allocation, network and service orchestration, assurance—all critical items
to NFV that are also very much central for network slicing to function.
In addition, with its 5G trial platform, Intel is involved in numerous trials around the globe, providing 5G
reference architecture for proof of concept with customers, and activities pulling in participants from vertical
industries to develop business cases and requirements for 5G services and network slicing.
For additional insights from Intel on 5G Network Slicing ecosystem challenges and building collaboration for
business case development and standards, see the video interviews conducted by Strategy Analytics’ Susan Welsh
de Grimaldo on RCR Wireless website:
x Video interview with Dr. Geng Wu https://www.rcrwireless.com/20171024/wireless/analyst-angle-video-
interview-intels-dr-geng-wu-5g-network-slicing
x Video interview with Caroline Chan https://www.rcrwireless.com/20171024/wireless/analyst-angle-video-
interview-intels-caroline-chan-5g-network-slicing
“The new set of challenges and also the opportunity is how you actually transform the network
with technology to serve the many new sets of applications, new industries and actually enable
the next round of innovation.” Dr. Geng Wu, Intel
“For 5G, you have to expand your ecosystem…start talking to folks you don’t normally talk to,
you understand who actually pays the bill, who is willing to adopt your technology. So be willing
to try, expand your horizon, and all this is possible because the underlying network is much
more flexible and soft.” Caroline Chan, Intel
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 18 of 19
5.2 InterDigital: Developing Key Standards, Building Blocks for 5G Network Slicing
As a technology company focused on developing intellectual property, InterDigital is active in
standards development organizations (SDOs) working on defining 5G and coordination among SDOs.
InterDigital’s Akbar Rahman, Sr. Principal Engineer, shared his insights on work taking place at the Internet
Engineering Task Force (IETF) Standards body to determine what needs to be developed into standards for
internet protocols to support 5G network slicing and related precursor activities.
At IETF, 5G Network Slicing is currently a hot topic and IETF is actively coordinating with 3GPP for IP
infrastructure requirements to support Network Slicing. IETF has recently kicked off a pre-Working Group effort to
identify what needs to be standardized to support 5G Network Slicing. While the group has not yet reached
consensus, several areas to potentially include have been identified:
x network topology data models (e.g. YANG)
x protocol encapsulation
x signalling to connect subnet slices
x performance measurement, traffic engineering, etc.
– https://datatracker.ietf.org/group/netslicing/meetings/
Collaborative Research & Development on key elements supporting 5G network slicing: In addition to its
work at SDOs, InterDigital is involved in a number of collaborative R&D efforts that are tackling elements that feed
into network slicing. For example, many of the EU funded projects related to 5G are providing key designs for
network slicing using NFV/SDN building blocks. InterDigital is active in numerous EU funded projects including two
key projects related to network slicing:
5G PPP project – CROSSHAUL
Developing a virtualized high speed (sliceable) backhaul and front-haul network to connect a large number of 5G
Base Stations to the Mobile Core Network. https://5g-ppp.eu/xhaul/
H2020 project – POINT
Developing a virtualized underlay network fabric (sliceable) to run IP based services that provide superior
performance by name base routing, fast indirection, intrinsic multicast support, etc. https://www.point-h2020.eu/
To support dynamic slicing, “some business relationship has to be available…the operator
might have the most dynamic network slicing system available, but if they have no way to
advertise the APIs, no way to charge for it…I believe the mobile operators will start becoming
like Amazon or Google where they offer APIs and basically a credit card or some other
electronic charging system… ” Akbar Rahman, InterDigital
Service Providers
Copyright © Strategy Analytics 2017 | www.strategyanalytics.com 19 of 19
6. How Can We Help You?
Strategy Analytics provides strategic and tactical support to global clients through a range of customized
solutions:
• Multi-Country primary research assignments using leading edge tools and
techniques
• User Experience Design and Innovation engagements
• Real Time Mobile Consumer On-Device Tracking projects
• B2B Consulting Projects and Whitepapers
Please contact us at Custom@strategyanalytics.com with any questions and for further details on how we
can work with you to create a custom solution that addresses your specific needs.